Produced by the Office of Pastoral Ministries and Faith Formation
Security in Silence
By Peggy Sue Mutchler
Program and Events Coordinator
Have you ever found yourself in a dire situation, but you could not pray? A situation where prayer seemed impossible? You wanted to pray — you even knew you needed to — but no words, no thoughts, no emotion came, just silence. Physically, you shut down into an unexplained calm. And in that moment, you realized that God even hears your silence.
It was October 7, 2022 — the feast day of Our Lady of the Rosary — when I received the phone call no parent ever wants to receive, nor was it a phone call that 99% of the population would ever receive . . .
“Your son was caving, and we have help on the way, but he is stuck in a passage and has been stuck for about three hours.”
Instant calm. Not the reaction one would think. I found myself in God’s peace; it is the only explanation.
“Do not worry about anything, but in everything by prayer and supplication with thanksgiving let your requests be made known to God. And the peace of God, which surpasses all understanding, will guard your hearts and your minds in Christ Jesus.” -Philippians 4:6-7
What do I do?
“Commit your way to the Lord; trust in Him, and He will act.” -Psalm 37:5
I had to go to the cave. I couldn’t stay away. As God so orchestrated, my husband was working from home that day; however, we also had two young daughters we couldn’t leave alone, or bring with us. Just at that moment, another God-send, our daughter Trinity, unexpectedly walked in the door from college. A quick explanation, and we were out the door. The three girls stayed home and began to pray the Rosary.
The Rosary is Mary’s shield for her children. I was so grateful to know my daughters were praying, because again, I tried to pray, but my mind blanked, and I could not even pray one complete Hail Mary, let alone a Rosary. I was dependent on God in my silence.
“Cast all of your anxieties on Him, because He cares for you.” -1 Peter 5:7
My husband and I arrived at the location and were led to the mouth of the cave, only to be met by a rescue team already putting strong efforts into play. It was evident by those present that our needs were to be met with compassion, love, and action. A moral sense of empathy, in which we tried our best to reciprocate. It is in that moment, we knew our faith must shine through the darkness. We must stay calm and put on the face of Christ in suffering. We must imitate our Mother Mary in her own witness to those around her while her own Son suffered.
“The message of the cross is foolishness to those who are perishing, but to us who are being saved it is the power of God.” -1 Corinthians 1:18
Our son was a member of a local caving group, but this trip was for his own recreation. He was doing what he did best, though: exploring and surveying caves, looking for new passages, and enjoying life. He was happy. All safety measures were met and strictly followed. No room for nonsense in this type of spelunking. Safety is taken very seriously. This expedition was no less.
With every safety measure in place, the group of three went into the cave for their exploratory trip. Surveying in this particular cave had been done time and time again, for year upon year. On this feast day of Our Lady, progress was made. A ‘new passage’ had been found; a new passage that led to a ‘new room’. Long story short, my son entered the newly discovered room alone, and when he turned around to exit, he found himself unable to do so. He tried one way. Then another. The third time, he couldn’t move at all. His body was stuck on a corridor corner, at a 90 degree angle. Only his head and one outstretched arm poked through the narrow opening into the pitch black passage, the passage which was used to crawl into the new room had now taken its grip. A potential clutch of death.
“The human mind plans the way, but the Lord directs the steps.” -Proverbs 16:9
The seriousness was not evidently met, but after thirty minutes of trying to free our son on their own, they saw the fruitlessness of their endeavors; one stayed in his presence and the other crawled for help back through the darkness and finally into the light of the earth’s surface once more. Help was alerted, phone calls were made, and professional rescue cavers were on their way.
“If we live, we live to the Lord, and if we die, we die to the Lord; so then, whether we live or whether we die, we are the Lord’s.” – Romans 14:8
My husband and I sat at the entrance of the cave, watching the late afternoon sun set. It was now pitch dark, except for the moon casting shadows of the pine. The cold autumn air was settling in; only a lantern lit the faces of those tirelessly giving of themselves. But not once did the realization that this incident could end with my son’s death — it never crossed my mind. God protected me.
The very first thing the rescuers did was run a WWII phone cable back to our son. This way, they could communicate with him. Finally, connection was made. They let us speak to our son. But, what to say, what to say. . . “Jesse, God is with you. You are not alone.”
I trusted. I never doubted. I knew God would work it out. My head was silent. My heart was still. My eyes intently watched and calmly observed those around us. The stillness was a gift. A gift from God. Sometimes, the most powerful prayer is simply sitting in God’s presence, knowing He is there.
“Be still, and know that I am.” – Psalm 46:10
I was given a vision, and still today, it is all I see.
The vision portrayed the cave as a warmly lit room, very inviting, like I imagine the scene of when Jesus was born. Warm and snug. A loving space. This vision I was given, included my son and his rescuers all in close proximity, chatting, laughing, loving. A calmness was in the air — the mesmerizing glow of a crackling fire surrounded the cave, giving the atmosphere its warmth. All peaceful, all okay. My head and heart were kept from the tragic thoughts, kept from the reality of death that was wanting to grip my son. Even though Jesse was a slave to the unknown, wedged within the 8” x 22” opening of the tunnel passage which was holding his body captive, I was being wrapped in the warmth of Our Lady’s Mantle—I feel Jesse was too.
I found myself in a position I could not control, nor could my husband, nor could the rescue team, which had now grown in multiples.
“Present your bodies as a living sacrifice, holy and acceptable to God, which is your spiritual worship. Do not be conformed to this world, but be transformed by the renewing of your minds, so that you may discern what is the will of God — what is good and acceptable and perfect.” -Romans 12:1-2
Trinity, our college-aged daughter, who stepped in just as we were leaving home, joined the rescue team. God is so good that he sent our oldest daughter, Grace, to the house just as the cavers called Trinity in for backup. Timing impeccable. The team needed people familiar with this cave to lead rescuers to Jesse, so the rescuers themselves would not get lost, so they were calling in all who had experienced this cave. Our daughter was one. I now had two children within this potential death trap of a cave.
After all was said and done, these were people who gave up their day, their night, left their families to rescue mine. They did not complain. They were goal-oriented. They worked together. They used teamwork. Their skills complimented each other. They lifted each other up. It gave us much hope in this world.
These men and women worked tirelessly through the night, eighteen hours to be exact.
Within those 18 hours hours, there was an abundance of planning, orchestrating, using teamwork, continual belly crawling in pitch black 56 degree temps, drilling minuscule pieces of rock—all to move an inch or two of limestone, so my son could be pulled to freedom. And he was. And he was untouched. Perfectly fine. No repercussions.
“It is no longer I who live, but it is Christ who lives in me. And the life I now live in the flesh, I live by faith in the Son of God, who loved me and gave himself for me.” – Galatians 2:20
God is good. All the time.
One year later, on this same feast day of Our Lady of the Rosary, my son was caving again. This time, a different cave, and this time, a series of new rooms were discovered. The biggest room being around 50 foot by 50 foot, too big to get stuck in. It is dubbed “Anniversary Hall” since it was to the exact day of “Jesse’s Jam”. But I know, that it was all part of God’s plan in honor of His Mother, as in Job, it states, “I know that You can do all things, and that no purpose of Yours can be thwarted.” We are in acknowledgment of God’s omnipotence and the unceasing nature of His plans. So, if you find yourself in a state of suffering so great that you go docile, know that God hears you in your silence.
Monthly Reflection Archives
https://www.rapidcitydiocese.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/04/Website-Post-Header-2.jpg
924
1640
Jacques Daniel
https://www.rapidcitydiocese.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/02/WebHeader22-1.png
Jacques Daniel2026-04-30 15:02:532026-04-30 15:34:25Monthly Reflection by the Office of Faith Formation: May 2026
https://www.rapidcitydiocese.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/04/Website-Post-Header-1.jpg
924
1640
Jacques Daniel
https://www.rapidcitydiocese.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/02/WebHeader22-1.png
Jacques Daniel2026-04-08 12:29:302026-04-08 12:29:30Monthly Reflection by the Office of Faith Formation: April 2026
https://www.rapidcitydiocese.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/03/MarchWebHeaderMorningStar.jpg
924
1640
Jacques Daniel
https://www.rapidcitydiocese.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/02/WebHeader22-1.png
Jacques Daniel2026-03-03 16:57:022026-03-06 09:48:53Monthly Reflection by the Office of Faith Formation: March 2026
https://www.rapidcitydiocese.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/01/Jan26.jpg
924
1640
Jacques Daniel
https://www.rapidcitydiocese.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/02/WebHeader22-1.png
Jacques Daniel2026-01-06 13:10:432026-01-06 14:42:06Monthly Reflection by the Office of Faith Formation: January 2026

